Best v HMRC, 2014 UKFTT 077 TC – inheritance tax business property relief case

The First-tier Tribunal has held that a deceased businessman’s trading estate management company did not qualify for inheritance tax business property relief as its activities were predominately investment related.

The business owned a plot of land with a disused factory which had been converted into a trading estate with units rented for light industry and offices. As well as letting the land, the family managed the site and provided various facilities for those on the site including electricity, fax services, free parking, a full-time manager on site and a forklift truck and use of a full-time driver.

This is from the report of the decision of the tribunal:

“The non-investment services provided by the Company include the  forklift truck service and the provision of office type facilities. We do not consider that those additional services predominate when considering the activities of the Company as a whole. Even if we were to take out the Burdens side of the business, the real nature of the business remains an investment business exploiting the land by granting tenancies and licences. Most of the income from additional services relates to re-charges for electricity, telephone and postage. The income from the other additional services is very modest compared to the licence fee income. Considering the facts by reference to the nature of the activities and the income produced by those activities puts the Business Centre well towards the investment end of the spectrum.”

The full report can be found here.

Tags: ,

Comments are closed.